How Do I Know If It Is My Inner Critic or Just Realistic Thinking?

By January 10, 2012 14 Comments

How do I know if it’s my inner critic talking, or if I’m just being realistic?

This is a really important question: how do I know if it’s just my inner critic telling me I can’t do something, I’m not good enough, I’m bound to fail, I’m not ready? How do I know it’s not the voice of reason?

Meet Claire.

Claire was a client of mine who dreamed of being an entrepreneur. For over two decades she worked in senior roles in various retail companies, knowing that her passion lay with a vision to start her own.

Her inner critic regularly chattered in her head about how she didn’t have what it took to be successful, and that pursuing the dream would be financially irresponsible toward her family. Her musings about this possibility had, for many years, sounded like this:

“I would love to start a retail business, I would love the independence and challenge. I feel like it’s what I am meant to do…But I don’t have what that takes. People who start businesses need much more experience, and a broader skill set. I don’t have the access to capital either. And doing this would be irresponsible to my family. I would be putting them in great financial risk.”

How do we know if this is her inner critic talking or if she’s making a good assessment of the situation? Clearly, everyone doesn’t have the skills to start a successful retail business — and there is such a thing as rationally evaluating our deficits and capacity. But we can recognize this voice as the inner critic in Claire by a few clues:

· It is making a definite pronouncement, with very little evidence to back it up. It’s interested in “the way things are” (this is always a red flag!).
· It’s undertaking a premature evaluation of the question, “Is it possible, or not?” rather than wondering, “What could be possible?” or — even better, “How can I make this possible?”
· It’s stuck, repetitive. No real action is inspired by it. Real thinking always inspires some kind of forward movement.
· The energy behind the mental chatter is one of self- critique rather than self-care.
· The intention is shutting down forward movement, rather than opening up problem solving.

Here’s how thinking on the same topic could go, without the inner critic:

“I would love to start a retail business, I would love the independence and challenge. I feel like it’s what I am meant to do…I don’t know if I have what is needed. Hmmm…I wonder how I could find out what is needed and see how that fits with where I am. I wonder how I could start acquiring what I need. I’ll do x to learn more about that this week…feels exciting! And, I’m really committed to supporting my family financially. I wonder how I can do this and maintain that support. That’s important to me and I really don’t want to give it up.”

You can hear the different feeling-sense in the second example. In the second example you can hear curiosity, investigation, creativity and generative thinking.

Isn’t it interesting how the second line of thought is actually much more rational? There is an interest in real information gathering. There is a focus on the topic itself – not on ego stuff about one’s own worth or merit. The second way of thinking rapidly leads to action, because no mental junk is standing in the way of the path forward.

You can recognize your critic by how it speaks to you. Is it making grand proclamations about reality or about the worst-case scenarios? Is it repeating the same thing over and over again? That’s the critic. Good, realistic, sound thinking examines the situation with a light heart and a focus on solutions. Feel the difference?



Join the discussion 14 Comments

We are on a mission to help you realize your playing big dream.
Dive into our resources here: